Should HR enforce a “Christmas shutdown”?

Is it still acceptable to ask employees to take their annual leave during the Christmas holiday? Sarah Tahamtani examines the legal implications of an ‘Christmas shut down’.

Many UK businesses are faced with a dilemma as the festive season approaches – how to run their business during the Christmas period.

The annual “shutdown” between Christmas and New Year’s is a common practice for many. Employees are usually required to use some of their annual leaves during this period.

This approach is not suitable for a diverse and modern workplace, where some employees do not celebrate Christmas, or prefer to take their holidays at another time.

The issue of flexible working patterns is a hot topic for business. However, it remains unclear whether employers should provide greater flexibility in terms of when employees take annual leave, how this could affect workplace productivity, and what legal and practical considerations businesses must make.

Legal Considerations

Employers may legally require their employees to take annual leave during a specific time.

Working Time Regulations of 1998 allow employers to specify the date employees will take leave, if they provide sufficient notice. The notice is usually twice as long as the leave period the employee must take.

This framework is used by many employers to close their operations during the Christmas season. The rationale behind this is that it offers extended time off for employees while also accounting for possible drops in productivity.

Employers should take a reasonable approach and look at the individual circumstances of each employee when enforcing leave periods.

Inclusion and flexibility

Employees may be more motivated and happier if they have more time off during Christmas.

In a modern and diverse workplace, where flexibility and choice are motivating factors for employees, the traditional Christmas shut down has its limitations.

Some employees may not celebrate Christmas or may choose to use their annual leave for other religious holidays or family obligations at other times of the year.

Assuming that all employees want time off for Christmas is a mistake. It fails to recognize the diverse circumstances and preferences within a workforce.

In a tightening labour market, a ‘one size fits all’ approach can lead to resentment and disengagement. This could damage employee morale and productivity.

Flexible annual leave policies can contribute to an inclusive and supportive workplace, allowing employees more control over this benefit.

Balanced Approach

As always, greater flexibility demands a balanced approach.

The key considerations are whether employees can be effective on days that the majority of colleagues do not work and if the alternative dates they choose (which could be busier) will have an impact on the workload and service of their colleagues.

Employee consultations can be used to identify and develop strategies that strike the right balance between organisational requirements and individual preferences.

Early communication and advanced planning can mitigate potential problems, such as staff shortages or conflicts at other times during the year. They also allow for a more personal approach to employee rewards and benefits.

Transparency is key

Conversations about flexible working have shifted the expectations of employees on their work-life balance. Employees now seek greater autonomy in their own schedules and when they decide to take annual leave.

A traditional Christmas shutdown is still appropriate for certain businesses. However, a diverse workforce needs a more nuanced approach.

It’s unlikely that there will be a universal answer, but employers who view this as a chance to show inclusivity and flexibility can expect to see significant improvements in employee engagement and morale.

Employers must ensure that they have a transparent and open dialogue with their employees to give them the opportunity to express themselves, while also taking into account the business needs.

Employee preferences are important to employers. They can have a positive impact on employee satisfaction, wellbeing and productivity.

Personnel Today offers a number of opportunities for change management.

Browse Change Management Jobs